In a recent review, beauty enthusiast Amanda Krause tested four popular drugstore concealers to determine which product delivers the best results. Ranging in price from $6 to $12.99, the concealers are widely available at major retailers such as Ulta Beauty and Target.
The four contenders were L.A. Girl’s HD Pro Conceal, Maybelline’s Instant Age Rewind Eraser, NYX’s Bare With Me Serum, and e.l.f. Cosmetics’ Hydrating Camo Concealer. Each product was tested over a week, applied in a consistent manner with moisturizer and foundation before the concealer was added.
Performance Review of Each Concealer
Starting with the most affordable option, L.A. Girl’s HD Pro Conceal priced at $6, the product is known for its extensive shade range of 42 colors. While it provided decent coverage, Krause noted that it felt heavy on her skin and struggled to conceal blemishes effectively. Additionally, it emphasized dry patches, which diminished its overall appeal for her skin type.
The next product tested was NYX’s Bare With Me Serum, priced at $12. This concealer has gained significant attention on social media, boasting ingredients like tremella mushroom that aim to hydrate the skin. Krause found that this product fulfilled its promises, effectively covering acne and dark circles while providing a natural glow. Though it did show signs of creasing after a few hours, a quick touch-up with a beauty sponge restored its appearance.
Among the tested products, the Hydrating Camo Concealer from e.l.f. Cosmetics stood out as Krause’s favorite. Valued at $8, this concealer is celebrated for its lightweight feel while offering full coverage. It has been a staple for Krause since 2020, consistently delivering impressive results in concealing redness and blemishes.
Conclusion on the Best Drugstore Concealers
Finally, Maybelline’s Instant Age Rewind Eraser, priced at $12.99, offered a lightweight formula that left a radiant finish. While Krause appreciated its effectiveness, she typically reserved it for days when her skin was clearer, as it provided medium coverage rather than the full coverage she often prefers.
Ultimately, while each concealer had its strengths, Krause concluded that the e.l.f. Cosmetics Hydrating Camo Concealer remains her top choice for everyday use. Its combination of affordability and effective coverage makes it a standout in the drugstore category. While many viral beauty trends may come and go, these concealers offer lasting appeal for those looking to enhance their makeup routine.
