TheaterWorks Hartford has extended its run of the critically acclaimed play “The Counter” through March 22, 2024, due to overwhelming audience demand. The production, written by Meghan Kennedy, blends stark realism with theatrical flair, captivating viewers with its intimate depiction of human connection within the confines of a diner.
Set in a nearly empty diner, the play’s exquisite scenic design evokes the essence of an Edward Hopper painting. The atmosphere is a deliberate nod to the balance between realism and theatricality that defines Kennedy’s script, which premiered off-Broadway in the fall of 2024. The story revolves around Katie, portrayed by Justis Bolding, the diner’s sole morning employee, and her first customer, Paul, played by Tim DeKay.
Their conversations begin as light small talk but quickly delve into deeper, more personal topics. The narrative cleverly shifts from casual banter to significant confessions, exploring themes of escape and belonging. The relationship between Katie and Paul takes an unexpected turn when an inappropriate request emerges, illustrating the tension between naturalism and dramatic theatrics.
Kennedy’s play is filled with surprises, some of which are skillfully orchestrated while others feel more spontaneous. In one pivotal moment, a third character, played by Erika Rolfsrud, bursts onto the scene, injecting a fresh wave of emotional energy. Additionally, a series of 27 voice messages from a character not physically present adds depth to Katie’s backstory, enhancing the play’s complexity.
A significant prop in the production serves as a catalyst for Paul’s future, contributing to the play’s unpredictable trajectory. Viewers find themselves anticipating certain outcomes, only to be met with unexpected twists that keep the narrative alive and engaging.
The performances by Bolding and DeKay, under the direction of Rob Ruggiero, stand out for their authenticity. DeKay, known for his role in the series “White Collar,” brings a nuanced approach to his character, making even the most clichéd lines feel genuine. Bolding complements this with her physicality, delivering strong reactions that resonate with the audience.
The production runs for a concise 75 minutes, maintaining a brisk pace that prevents any dull moments. The simplicity of the staging, where characters remain in their everyday attire despite the passage of time, adds to the realism of the piece. This stylistic choice allows the audience to focus on the unfolding drama rather than the spectacle of costume changes.
Kennedy’s writing, rooted in traditional theatrical techniques, defies expectations as it progresses. The plot remains mysterious until the final moments, steering clear of predictable conclusions. Just when the narrative threatens to veer into sensationalism, it takes a gentle turn, leaving audiences with a sense of hope rather than despair.
“The Counter” offers a unique exploration of friendship and human connection, challenging conventional storytelling while providing a fresh perspective on the everyday lives of its characters. The production continues at TheaterWorks Hartford, located at 233 Pearl St., Hartford. Performances take place from Tuesday to Friday at 19:30, with matinees on Saturday and Sunday at 14:30. Ticket prices range from $25 to $78. For more information, visit twhartford.org.
