URGENT UPDATE: The Hawaii County Salary Commission is facing significant public backlash over a proposed 15.29% pay increase for top officials, set to be discussed at a crucial meeting in Hilo on December 22, 2025, at 10 a.m. The proposed raises, which include increments of 3.5% in January 2026 and 4% in July 2027 and 2028, have sparked heated debate amid economic uncertainty.
During a meeting on Monday, public testimony revealed widespread concern about the fiscal implications of these raises. Keaukaha resident Dell Otsuka stated, “Granting these raises at this time is not fiscally acceptable to me. Our county’s future depends upon your decision.” This sentiment resonates deeply as many residents are grappling with economic challenges and rising costs of living.
The commission, composed of nine members, currently has only six seated. A unanimous vote is needed for any increase over 10%, but the raises can still be approved in smaller increments with just five affirmative votes. Public criticism has been fierce, with many residents questioning the justification for comparing county salaries to private sector executives.
Megan Isaac, a local business operator, described the proposed increases as “grossly insensitive,” pointing out that the county’s tourism sector is experiencing a downturn. “A historically significant raise came to the executives in 2024, the largest ever, over 27%,” she noted, underscoring that the current proposals lack performance-based justification.
Hamakua resident Kevin Hill highlighted the county’s $953 million budget for 2026, advocating for salary cuts instead of increases. “We are positioning for insolvency,” Hill wrote in his testimony, reflecting a growing concern among residents about the sustainability of county finances.
Laila Moiré-Selvage expressed that the pay hike proposal reveals “a fundamental disconnect from the economic reality faced by the majority of Hawaii County residents.” She emphasized that prioritizing raises for top officials sends a troubling message during these challenging times, stating, “the financial well-being of government executives is prioritized over the immediate welfare and stability of the general public.”
The proposed increases would see Mayor Kimo Alameda’s salary rise incrementally from $209,028 to $242,892, with other officials like Managing Director Bill Brilhante and County Prosecutor Kelden Waltjen also set for significant raises. For example, Prosecutor Waltjen’s salary would increase from $197,004 to $228,912 by 2028.
The final vote on the proposed raises is expected at the December commission meeting. Local residents are urged to attend and voice their opinions. The outcome of this decision could have lasting implications on the county’s fiscal health and the quality of services provided to residents.
Tiffany Edwards-Hunt poignantly remarked, “People are struggling with hunger in Hawaii County right now.” As the public waits for the commission’s decision, the pressure is mounting for officials to reconsider the timing and justification of these proposed salary hikes.
Stay tuned for further updates on this developing story.
