UPDATE: New York lawmakers are gearing up for a heated debate over the controversial Raise the Age law, with urgent calls for reform as the new legislative session approaches. This law, enacted in 2017, prevents youth offenders aged 16 and 17 from being tried as adults, significantly altering the state’s criminal justice landscape.
The incoming New York City mayor, Zohran Mamdani, has appointed Jessica Tisch as the new NYPD Commissioner, who is advocating for immediate changes to this policy. Tisch stated, “Though I believe that the law was well-intentioned, we need now to roll up our sleeves and make adjustments based on the realities we are seeing on the ground.” This sentiment was echoed by district attorneys statewide, including Bronx DA Darcel Clark and Brooklyn DA Eric Gonzalez, both of whom discussed the law’s future at the recent SOMOS conference in Puerto Rico.
The urgency surrounding this discussion is underscored by alarming crime statistics. Tisch highlighted that the number of children involved in shootings has skyrocketed by 83% since the law’s implementation, with youth offenders now implicated in nearly 100% of such incidents. “The data is telling us a very clear, stark story. We need to listen to that data,” she emphasized during a Citizens Budget Commission event.
While some lawmakers, like Assemblywoman Latrice Walker, defend the current law, arguing it allows judges necessary discretion in youth cases, the push for reform is gaining momentum. Walker stated, “Hopefully, we will continue to allow the judges the discretion they need to make the best decisions.” However, she remains firmly opposed to changing the policy.
The District Attorneys Association of the State of New York (DAASNY) is also pressuring legislators for reform. DAASNY President Mary Pat Donnelly remarked, “We need to be able to look at the offender’s history… We need the ability to know what’s going on in family courts.” The current system complicates cases involving youth offenders, as these cases are typically handled in family court, which lacks transparency for law enforcement and prosecutors.
Governor Kathy Hochul has yet to take a definitive stance on the calls for change. Her office reiterated her commitment to reviewing all laws, saying, “I will be looking at all the laws as I get back to the legislative session.” Hochul’s position is crucial as she prepares for a challenging re-election campaign next year against likely Republican nominee Rep. Elise Stefanik.
The ongoing negotiations highlight a divide among lawmakers and stakeholders. Members of the state’s Black, Puerto Rican, Hispanic, and Legislative Caucus are advocating for improved funding and resources rather than changes to the law itself. Caucus chair Assemblywoman Michaelle Solages stated, “Raise the Age was established to protect children… Major policy decisions belong in the public legislative process.”
As discussions continue, all eyes will be on the upcoming legislative session, where the fate of the Raise the Age law hangs in the balance. With the stakes this high, any amendments will significantly impact how New York handles youth offenders moving forward. The urgency for reform, combined with the complexities of public safety and juvenile justice, makes this a critical issue for all New Yorkers.
