UPDATE: The future of New York’s ambitious climate law is under intense scrutiny as the state Legislature conducts a critical budget hearing on energy today, January 31, 2024. Questions regarding potential rollbacks of the Climate Leadership and Community Protection Act (CLCPA) emerged prominently, raising alarms among environmental advocates and lawmakers alike.
The hearing is a pivotal moment as it assesses Gov. Kathy Hochul’s proposed executive budget. The Coalition for Safe and Reliable Energy recently filed a petition with the Public Service Commission, urging a suspension or modification of obligations under the state’s Renewable Energy Program. This petition leverages a provision in the CLCPA that allows for adjustments if the program risks electric service reliability or increases service disconnections, according to the coalition’s claims.
With just 30 days for public comment, the coalition, primarily composed of business interests, has sparked significant concern among climate advocates. Rory M. Christian, chair and CEO of the Public Service Commission, refrained from discussing the petition during the hearing, leaving many unanswered questions.
As discussions unfold, State Sen. Pete Harckham pressed Amanda Lefton, commissioner of the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation, for insight into the governor’s plans. While she did not disclose specifics, she acknowledged the need for balancing climate action with affordability and reliability. “The governor has made clear that she knows we need to continue to fight climate change,” Lefton stated, emphasizing the importance of achieving multiple state goals.
The implications of potential rollbacks have galvanized both supporters and opponents of the CLCPA. State Sen. Mark Walczyk expressed optimism over the discussions, stating, “We’ve seen just a crack in her energy plan… This isn’t a good plan, it’s not feasible.” This sentiment resonates with GOP lawmakers who have long criticized the CLCPA as impractical.
Hochul has multiple opportunities to introduce new policy proposals during the budget process, including potential amendments within the next 30 days. Last year’s budget process extended into early May, highlighting the contentious nature of these discussions. Lawmakers are keenly aware that modifications to the climate law could emerge as major points of contention.
The hearing also spotlighted Hochul’s controversial proposal to revise the state’s environmental quality review process, aimed at boosting housing development. Critics, including State Sen. Rachel May, argue that the governor’s approach is too broad and lacks the nuance needed for specific housing projects. “Our bill is much more targeted… it has a lot of specifics when it comes to environmental protection,” May asserted.
As the budget negotiations progress, the stakes are high for New York’s climate future. Advocates and lawmakers alike are closely watching how these discussions will unfold, with potential ramifications for the state’s environmental objectives and overall energy strategy.
Stay tuned for updates as this story develops, with critical decisions expected in the coming weeks that could shape the future of New York’s climate legislation.
