URGENT UPDATE: The historic nativity scene display in Plainville, a tradition for over 25 years, has been canceled this year, igniting a firestorm of controversy among residents and local officials. The decision, announced just days before the holiday season, has drawn sharp criticism from the Plainville Republicans and raised questions about the role of government in religious displays.
In a series of Facebook posts, the Plainville Republicans condemned the absence of the nativity scene in Veterans Memorial Park. They allege that Democratic leadership on the Town Council requested a legal opinion from town attorney Morris Borea regarding the display without any public input or complaints. “The town was not asked by anyone to review the policy nor have there been any complaints about the nativity scene,” they stated, expressing disappointment over the lack of adherence to proper protocols.
The posts have garnered nearly 500 reactions and almost 150 comments, with many residents voicing their support for reinstating the nativity scene. “It’s refreshing to see so many in favor of the nativity scene,” the Republicans noted, highlighting the strong community sentiment surrounding the issue.
The controversy arose after Borea provided legal guidance indicating that a standalone nativity scene on town property could violate the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment, which prohibits government endorsement of religious views. Borea stated, “A standalone display on town property would likely violate the Establishment Clause and expose the town to litigation.”
In a letter dated December 21, 2023, released following a Freedom of Information request, Borea outlined his concerns about the nativity scene, suggesting that government endorsement of Christianity would result from its display. He emphasized that “continuous tradition does not immunize Plainville from constitutional challenges.”
Borea noted that the town has two possible alternatives: incorporating the nativity scene into a larger, secular holiday display or establishing a neutral public forum policy that would allow various community groups to display holiday decorations. “Plainville may display the nativity scene this year only if it is part of a broader, inclusive holiday display,” he concluded.
Republican leaders expressed frustration, suggesting that a simple solution might have been to add secular decorations alongside the nativity scene. They also indicated that the Town Council is expected to convene soon to establish a policy regarding holiday displays moving forward.
As the community grapples with this divisive issue, the Town Council has yet to respond to inquiries about their next steps. The chair of the Plainville Democratic Town Committee did not provide comments regarding the situation.
This developing story highlights the ongoing tension between religious expression and governmental policy in public spaces, raising questions about the future of holiday traditions in Plainville. As discussions continue, residents are left wondering what the town’s next move will be. Stay tuned for updates as this situation unfolds.
